I miss the opportunity to discuss the movies we guess:
– Sometimes I'm so sure I know the film, its title is on the tip of my tongue … it would be cool to speculate with other clueless users.
– There are so many movies I haven't seen (well, judging from some snapshots I haven't missed anything ;-) ) but many snapshots look intriguing or interesting or just completely weird so it would be great to find out more (and more than imdb can offer), e.g. why anyone would bother to by the DVD :-) or compare movies, find other fans of a special movie, exchange favourite scenes …
Of course, I'm well aware of the major drawback: The point of this site is to guess the movie so the discussion shouldn't give anything away. On the other side I've watched some movies now only because I discovered them here and they were well worth watching!
Maybe something like that discussions can only be started after the 30 day period? What do you think? Anyone else interested?
I think this is a great idea. If the solution can be asked anyway, why not help each other in the comments? At least there will still be some game element then. There should be some voting system, that if someone makes a useless comment or spoils the fun, the comment can be voted off.
To discuss a movie that hasn't "expired" yet (30 day limit), it's really difficult, as too many people would probably give away the answer. There would have to be enough mods to oversee these threads/the section (the forum should be devided into categories :) ).
As for movies that have already expired, I agree that there could be a comment section added beneath the shot. However, it should only be visible if you want it to (show it via a button), as a lot of people (including myself) still try to solve the movies even after they don't count for the highscore anymore, and the comments could really spoil the fun if they were always visible.