Vanilla is a product of Lussumo. More Information: Documentation, Community Support.
-
-
CommentAuthorforerunner
- CommentTimeJun 8th 2009
seems to be fixed already sara -
-
yup, the vote-delete function is doing a great job :D
-
-
CommentAuthorforerunner
- CommentTimeJun 18th 2009 edited
Post deleted, nevermind -
-
No, I don't think so.
-
Aren't these dupes ?
old one: http://whatthemovie.com/shot/4704
submitted one: http://whatthemovie.com/shot/21886 -
gregoire, now everyone knows the answer to the last one......
I tagged it for deletion -
-
CommentAuthorLePaposaure
- CommentTimeJun 19th 2009
Other shot from the same scene, but not dupes. -
-
not a dupe, still don't know the movie by the way :(
-
now you disappoint me LordMyst........
-
- CommentAuthorDiedEnFreek
- CommentTimeJun 19th 2009 edited
For history purposes : http://whatthemovie.com/shot/21886 linked to
and was tagged as dupe of
And see those HUGE BLACK BARS!!!! ;) -
-
CommentAuthorLePaposaure
- CommentTimeJun 20th 2009
Yeah, those black bars are totally a shame ! What are doing moderators ?! -
-
As far as the previously discussed dupe - the rules state that you should take a shot from the same scene as a previous shot, not just that they should be the same exact shot. Based on this, I think it should be considered a dupe. The point is not that you can use one to find the answer to the other. It is just that anyone who gets the first one is going to get the second one too.
Along the same line, I consider this http://whatthemovie.com/shot/22505 to be a dupe of this http://whatthemovie.com/shot/19314 . Does anyone else agree, or am I on my own now. -
For some reason that example doesn't bother me . . but I see what you are saying . . . I guess I consider the shots just different enough . . . but I would understand it being deleted as a dupe if it was my upload . . . I think the same thing happened recently with 2 shots from Lock, Stock . . .
-
-
CommentAuthorforerunner
- CommentTimeJun 24th 2009 edited
these shots are voted for deletion for being dupes.
Not sure if they are/still are.
http://whatthemovie.com/shot/20299
http://whatthemovie.com/shot/20307
http://whatthemovie.com/shot/20320 -
-
I don't see the supposed dupes for those shots anywhere ???
-
I think those votes go back to when those shots were in New Submissions section. They were uploaded several times. But their "twins" have been deleted. Votes remain, though...
-
OK . that makes sense . . . :)
-
-
CommentAuthorforerunner
- CommentTimeJun 24th 2009
okay, nevermind then -
-
-
CommentAuthorguustflaterke
- CommentTimeJun 28th 2009
Ocean's Eleven is defined twice as movie. -
-
Ocean's Eleven (2001) http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0240772/ with Brad Pitt and George Clooney is a remake of Ocean's Eleven (1960) http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0054135/ with the Rat Pack.
-
-
CommentAuthorguustflaterke
- CommentTimeJun 28th 2009
Yeah,
I just realised it.
I will have to see the original. -
-
Another dupe (not exact, but easily close enough for me to remember the first and use it to solve the second):
http://whatthemovie.com/shot/22983
Edit: link removed -
Mh not really astrodo, it's from two totally different scenes and it looks different... wouldn't really say that it's a dupe (but it's just my opinion) ;)
-
Please don't post here links for non-exact dupes. If the new snapshot finally gets through, there'll be no fun in guessing it.
Don't do it in your deletion-vote comment either, just drop a shout if you can. -
From the upload page:
Don't upload a snapshot from the same scene or with similar content (e.g. the same character).
This may not be the same scene, but it's definitely similar content. -
honnestly, I really dont see these as dupes, if you didn't post them here, I wouldn't have automatically made the link... With shots from animations especially, there is a big chance you will find the same characters sometimes, I think dupes should be really shots that look similar, this is not the case here imo
-
I don't know, if we started enforcing the rule that dupes include the same character in different scenes, it would get rid of Johnny Depp completely ;-)
I see your point that the same characters will appear with animations, but this makes them extremely easy. This is because there are a small number of shots on the site that are animation, and they can easily be found with the 'anime' or 'animation' tags. So you can just search for these tags, and find which previous shots have the same characters (this isn't how I did it - I just remembered the previous shot). You can even compare the number of languages in an anime movie to archived movies to figure it out, which may mean the problem is with the tags and not with dupes. -
I'm pretty sure we have this one ( http://whatthemovie.com/shot/22989 ) in the database already. However, it was uploaded a looooong time ago ...
-
-
CommentAuthorLePaposaure
- CommentTimeJun 30th 2009
I agree with you, Sara, but impossible to find it (as I don't know the title of the movie...). -
-
;-) I happen to know the title but this specific shot doesn't show on the movie's page, I think the uploader might have looked there and then thought the scene's still free.
What's nice though: Many movies seem to have key scenes which are appreciated by wtm-ers equally. -
And now everybody can solve it...
-
And nobody scores a point, when it is deleted ...
-
So you're actually *telling* it's a dupe, not asking.
-
Well, thank you very much. :-(
I would say they were two shots of the same character from the same movie. Does that make them dupes? -
http://whatthemovie.com/shot/23346
There was a previous shot with this character in the same scene, but was a slightly different shot (included another character). Should this be considered a dupe?
I guess we need to make the reason for deleting duplicates clear. Should we delete duplicates:
1. so that it's not too easy to guess a shot by looking for similar shots in the archive.
or
2. just to make sure the exact same shot is not uploaded twice.
I personally think two shots from the same scene in a movie with the same characters should be considered dupes, even if they are doing different things. This is to prevent easy solves and to reduce the number of shots from each film. If only the same exact shot is considered a dupe, then we will end up with 100 shots of Fight Club and Aeon Flux before too long. -
I see what you mean about this shot Astrododo but in my view, this is not a dupe, there is a very long moment with more than one scene in this movie where we see this character(s) in the same place and here he is doing something very particular which makes the shot special imo. But I understand some might consider this differently... and I agree the dupe thingy should be better clarified
But to be honnest the more Fight Club and co posted now, the less there will be available later, cause people will be running out of shots eventually ha ha :) -
Hi, are these considered dupes?
http://whatthemovie.com/shot/23313 23313
http://whatthemovie.com/shot/23311 23311 -
They're two different movies
-
-
CommentAuthorguustflaterke
- CommentTimeJul 6th 2009
in big fish there is a dupe. -
-
http://whatthemovie.com/shot/23831 23831
First posted (too fast) and got then black bars (forgot to check that point. Soooooorrrrryyy). Got deleted. OK for me, i'm not going to complain. Have to try and make mistake to improve.
I loaded it again without black bars... and it's about to be deleted as dupe... I can't see the dupe either in the list of shots of the movie, nor in FF... I guess the one voting remember my first attempt yesterday. Or is there really a dupe ? Can someone show me the dupe ?
Feel a bit sad about the coming deletion... -
got deleted already... (the first attempt from yesterday is still visible in my profile as favourite - the girl in the tub).
My question remains : is there really a dupe except the one from yesterday ?
Thanks for your help. -
I don't think they were really dupes.
Next time, you should leave a warning as a tag. -
-
CommentAuthorguustflaterke
- CommentTimeJul 9th 2009
-
-
@guustflaterke
that's a old dupe. Long time ago we already established that is was a dupe. But it was never deleted. Why I don't know anymore. -
This is in the new submissions http://whatthemovie.com/shot/24356
and this is in FF http://whatthemovie.com/shot/23174
It's almost the same, what do you guys think? -
@Phoenix - that's a dupe IMHO, and the one in FF looks much higher quality. I thought I remembered that shot, but I didn't find it with a quick tag search.
-
Me neither astrodo... I've searched it then with the calendar and went through all the uploads until I found it :D Took me a bit until I had it ;)
And I thought the same, quality seemed to be low. -
- CommentAuthortoffetomas
- CommentTimeJul 13th 2009 edited
-
Oh I didn't see that one. It is a bit different, but it could make things easier if you only recognize one of them (unusual). Well, I leave this decision to the votes :(